Index: src/expr.c ================================================================== --- src/expr.c +++ src/expr.c @@ -1391,11 +1391,12 @@ case TK_FLOAT: case TK_BLOB: return 0; case TK_COLUMN: assert( p->pTab!=0 ); - return p->iColumn>=0 && p->pTab->aCol[p->iColumn].notNull==0; + return ExprHasProperty(p, EP_CanBeNull) || + (p->iColumn>=0 && p->pTab->aCol[p->iColumn].notNull==0); default: return 1; } } Index: src/resolve.c ================================================================== --- src/resolve.c +++ src/resolve.c @@ -318,10 +318,14 @@ } } if( pMatch ){ pExpr->iTable = pMatch->iCursor; pExpr->pTab = pMatch->pTab; + assert( (pMatch->jointype & JT_RIGHT)==0 ); /* RIGHT JOIN not (yet) supported */ + if( (pMatch->jointype & JT_LEFT)!=0 ){ + ExprSetProperty(pExpr, EP_CanBeNull); + } pSchema = pExpr->pTab->pSchema; } } /* if( pSrcList ) */ #ifndef SQLITE_OMIT_TRIGGER Index: src/sqliteInt.h ================================================================== --- src/sqliteInt.h +++ src/sqliteInt.h @@ -2012,11 +2012,11 @@ }; /* ** The following are the meanings of bits in the Expr.flags field. */ -#define EP_FromJoin 0x000001 /* Originated in ON or USING clause of a join */ +#define EP_FromJoin 0x000001 /* Originates in ON/USING clause of outer join */ #define EP_Agg 0x000002 /* Contains one or more aggregate functions */ #define EP_Resolved 0x000004 /* IDs have been resolved to COLUMNs */ #define EP_Error 0x000008 /* Expression contains one or more errors */ #define EP_Distinct 0x000010 /* Aggregate function with DISTINCT keyword */ #define EP_VarSelect 0x000020 /* pSelect is correlated, not constant */ @@ -2032,10 +2032,11 @@ #define EP_Static 0x008000 /* Held in memory not obtained from malloc() */ #define EP_MemToken 0x010000 /* Need to sqlite3DbFree() Expr.zToken */ #define EP_NoReduce 0x020000 /* Cannot EXPRDUP_REDUCE this Expr */ #define EP_Unlikely 0x040000 /* unlikely() or likelihood() function */ #define EP_Constant 0x080000 /* Node is a constant */ +#define EP_CanBeNull 0x100000 /* Can be null despite NOT NULL constraint */ /* ** These macros can be used to test, set, or clear bits in the ** Expr.flags field. */ Index: test/join5.test ================================================================== --- test/join5.test +++ test/join5.test @@ -104,7 +104,61 @@ } {} do_test join5-2.12 { execsql {SELECT * FROM xy LEFT JOIN ab ON NULL WHERE NULL} } {} +# Ticket https://www.sqlite.org/src/tktview/6f2222d550f5b0ee7ed37601 +# Incorrect output on a LEFT JOIN. +# +do_execsql_test join5-3.1 { + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t1; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t2; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t3; + CREATE TABLE x1(a); + INSERT INTO x1 VALUES(1); + CREATE TABLE x2(b NOT NULL); + CREATE TABLE x3(c, d); + INSERT INTO x3 VALUES('a', NULL); + INSERT INTO x3 VALUES('b', NULL); + INSERT INTO x3 VALUES('c', NULL); + SELECT * FROM x1 LEFT JOIN x2 LEFT JOIN x3 ON x3.d = x2.b; +} {1 {} {} {}} +do_execsql_test join5-3.2 { + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t1; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t2; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t3; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t4; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t5; + CREATE TABLE t1(x text NOT NULL, y text); + CREATE TABLE t2(u text NOT NULL, x text NOT NULL); + CREATE TABLE t3(w text NOT NULL, v text); + CREATE TABLE t4(w text NOT NULL, z text NOT NULL); + CREATE TABLE t5(z text NOT NULL, m text); + INSERT INTO t1 VALUES('f6d7661f-4efe-4c90-87b5-858e61cd178b',NULL); + INSERT INTO t1 VALUES('f6ea82c3-2cad-45ce-ae8f-3ddca4fb2f48',NULL); + INSERT INTO t1 VALUES('f6f47499-ecb4-474b-9a02-35be73c235e5',NULL); + INSERT INTO t1 VALUES('56f47499-ecb4-474b-9a02-35be73c235e5',NULL); + INSERT INTO t3 VALUES('007f2033-cb20-494c-b135-a1e4eb66130c', + 'f6d7661f-4efe-4c90-87b5-858e61cd178b'); + SELECT * + FROM t3 + INNER JOIN t1 ON t1.x= t3.v AND t1.y IS NULL + LEFT JOIN t4 ON t4.w = t3.w + LEFT JOIN t5 ON t5.z = t4.z + LEFT JOIN t2 ON t2.u = t5.m + LEFT JOIN t1 xyz ON xyz.y = t2.x; +} {007f2033-cb20-494c-b135-a1e4eb66130c f6d7661f-4efe-4c90-87b5-858e61cd178b f6d7661f-4efe-4c90-87b5-858e61cd178b {} {} {} {} {} {} {} {} {}} +do_execsql_test join5-3.3 { + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS x1; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS x2; + DROP TABLE IF EXISTS x3; + CREATE TABLE x1(a); + INSERT INTO x1 VALUES(1); + CREATE TABLE x2(b NOT NULL); + CREATE TABLE x3(c, d); + INSERT INTO x3 VALUES('a', NULL); + INSERT INTO x3 VALUES('b', NULL); + INSERT INTO x3 VALUES('c', NULL); + SELECT * FROM x1 LEFT JOIN x2 JOIN x3 WHERE x3.d = x2.b; +} {} finish_test