You could also use a simple correlated subquery if all you wanted was the concat of the applicable keywords: ``` select docs.id, docs.title AS Title, authors.author AS Author, docs.source) AS Source, ( select group_concat(keyword) from keywords where docid == D.docid and authorid == D.Authorid ) as Keywords from docs, authors where docs.authorid == authors.authorid and docs.docid == author.docid order by docs.id desc limit 5 ; ```